Update: Since written, Goldschmidt has resigned and Texas Pacific Group
has offered a miniscule $43 million in rate relief to customers.
Oregon's Department of Justice investigated Diana Goldschmidt and the
Oregon Investment Council on its additional $300 million investment
with Texas Pacific. The "limited" investigation found little wrong. In
addition, previously secret papers revealed that Texas Pacific expected
to make a $1 billion profit (as much as 38.4 percent a year) if it held
onto PGE for five years. On 3/10/2005, the Oregon PUC rejected the
Texas Pacific purchase of PGE as not being in the public interest.
Texas Pacific Group & Neil
Goldschmidt
Texas Pacific Group, based in Fort Worth, Texas, announced on
November 18, 2003 that it had reached an agreement with Enron to buy
PGE for $2.35 billion, including $1.1 billion in debt
costs/liabilities. Enron paid $3.1 billion for PGE in 1997.
Texas Pacific Group is a private company, exempt from SEC or any
other regulatory scrutiny. The company buys distressed companies and
then sells them a few years later for a profit ranging from 20 to 40
percent. Ratepayers can expect more uncertainty in the future. What
steps will Texas Pacific undertake to maximize its profit during its
short-term ownership? One thing is certain, PGE will
experience"revolving door" owners with no guarentee that a future owner
won't be as corrupt as Enron. History shows that the Oregon PUC won't
or can't protect ratepayers.
TPG made no mention of electricity rate cuts during its November
18 news conference announcing its offer. Bankruptcy Court approval,
along with federal and state regulatory approval, should take until
late 2004 or early 2005 and it's very possible the deal won't go
through.
Neil Goldschmidt, a former Oregon governor, is the most well
known public figurehead in the TPG offer. In Texas Pacific's Oregon
Public Utility Commission filing to buy PGE, it stated that Neil
Goldschmidt and Tom Walsh of Oregon, and Gary Grinstein of Washington
will invest $2.5 million in the venture BUT control 95% of the voting
stock. At the very least, the three will more than double their
investment in a few years when Texas Pacific sells Portland General.
There's a stategic reason for the three's control over voting stock,
that being that Oregon PERS, who is investing at least $300 million (71
percent of Texas Pacific's total investment) will have almost no say in
what the company does.
In addition, the three Northwesterners will profit in other ways
through the companies they own or control. That could be the big payoff
for them in the long run. Goldschmidt is already on Texas Pacific's
payroll. Tom Walsh owns a construction company and Gary Grinstein
controls numerous businesses.
Goldschmidt is a lobbyist and senior partner in the firm
Goldschmidt Imeson Carter. Whenever a major business deal occurs in
Oregon, there's a good likelihood Goldschmidt or his firm is involved
in some way. He helped facilitate the sale of Oregon's Willamette
Industries to Weyerhaeuser, an out-of-state company, at a cost of at
least 500 Oregon jobs. Goldschmidt also headed a commission for Energy
Northwest to find buyers for electricity that could be produced by the
mothballed Hanford. Will the Trojan Nuclear Plant be resurrected?
In early 2003, Goldschmidt was hired to co-chair a national
airline industry coalition to push a bill in Congress that would ban
the right of airline unions to strike.
Oregon's quasi-public State Accident Insurance Fund (SAIF)
disclosed in November 2003 that they hired Goldschmidt in 1996 as a
consultant. He was first paid hourly, then given a contract valued at
$5,000 a month, and eventually received $20,000 a month. Goldschmidt
received at least $1.1 million as SAIF's consultant/lobbyist. The
insurer has acknowledged that it did not follow normal procedures for
state contracts.
Sen. Vicki Walker, D-Eugene, filed an ethics complaint on
December 5, 2003 over the contracts with the state Government Standards
and Practices Commission. Walker’s complaint alleges that the payments
to Goldschmidt and Larry Campbell, another lobbyist, were over $1
million more than what SAIF previously reported. Goldschmidt canceled
his contract with SAIF on the same day the complaint was filed. As SAIF
and Goldschmidt have admitted there's no written work product (what he
did to receive such an enormous payoff) we may never know the extent of
his activities against the best interests of Oregon workers.
While governor in 2000, Goldschmidt was a driving force behind
inactment of Senate Bill 1197, a major workers' compensation system
overhaul. The major provision of the bill, exclusive remedy, was found
unconstitutional in 1995. SB 1197 provided negligent employers immunity
from civil claims even when injury claims were denied completely by the
workers' compensation system.
Neil Goldschmidt's wife Diana is a member of the Oregon
Investment Council. It decides where the Oregon Public Employees
Retirement Fund and other state funds are invested. Just days before
Goldschmidt became involved with the Texas group according to
statements he's made, the Council approved an additional $300 million
to be invested with Texas Pacific Group. Diana Goldschmidt voted to
approve the amount, $100 million over the normal cap for a single
investment. Oregon now has $950 million invested with the Texas group.
Oregon PERS lost $80 million due to Enron's bankruptcy, caused in large
part by company fraud.
Because Goldschmidt carries so much power in political circles
and will have a personal economic stake in maximizing profits,
ratepayers can expect to be gouged once again as they were by PGE's 41
percent rate increase in October 2001, the result of energy trading
fraud.